(404) 990-3945
VA Disability Attorneys | SSDI/SSI Attorneys
Top

Ingram v. Collins – Maximizing Your Musculoskeletal Ratings

|

Good days on medication should not hide how severe your service-connected back, knee, or joint condition is. A court decision called Ingram v. Collins may help veterans pursue ratings that reflect the full severity of many musculoskeletal conditions, and a rule change in early 2026 brought the case back into the news.

Key Takeaways

  • Ingram v. Collins requires the VA to estimate how severe many musculoskeletal conditions are in their baseline, unmedicated state when the diagnostic code does not mention medication, which may support a rating that reflects the true severity of your condition.
  • The VA’s February 2026 attempt to override Ingram was rescinded, and the Federal Circuit dismissed the VA’s appeal in March 2026, so the decision stands as final.
  • You should explicitly tell your C&P examiner which medications you take and precisely how those medications reduce your symptoms.
  • Documenting the relief your medication provides gives the examiner the factual baseline needed to determine the true underlying severity of your musculoskeletal condition.
  • Describe your symptoms accurately, and never stop taking your medication before an exam.
  • If your current rating was set while you were medicated, you may have options to seek a rating that better reflects your baseline.

What Is Ingram v. Collins?

Ingram v. Collins, 38 Vet. App. 130 (2025), is a decision from the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims, the court that reviews appeals of VA decisions. The case involved Carlton Ingram, an Army veteran rated 20% for a back disability and 10% for an ankle condition while taking prescription painkillers. The Board of Veterans’ Appeals denied him ratings under diagnostic codes based on limitation of motion, and the court rejected the VA’s reasoning.

Before Ingram, a rating for a musculoskeletal condition may have depended heavily on how the condition looked at an exam while you were medicated. If your medication eased your pain and improved your range of motion that day, the exam findings may have understated how limiting the condition is without it, and your rating may have stopped short of the highest level your condition supported.

The court held that when the VA evaluates a musculoskeletal condition under a diagnostic code that does not mention medication, the examiner must try to determine how severe the condition is without the benefit of treatment. This is called the baseline, or unmedicated, state. If the record does not show the baseline, the VA must gather more evidence.

A diagnostic code is the number the VA assigns to a condition in its rating schedule, along with the criteria used to set a percentage. Musculoskeletal conditions typically involve the back, neck, joints, and muscles.

Why Veterans Should Know About Ingram v. Collins

The Ingram v. Collins case returned to the headlines in 2026 when the VA tried to override it, but the effort did not last.

The situation surrounding the case unfolded along this summarized timeline:

  • March 12, 2025: The Veterans Court decided Ingram v. Collins.
  • February 17, 2026: The VA published an interim final rule, effective immediately, that would have based ratings on a veteran’s improved, medicated condition. The VA said Ingram may affect more than 500 diagnostic codes and 350,000 pending claims.
  • February 19, 2026: Within two days, Secretary Doug Collins halted enforcement after objections from veterans, advocacy groups, and members of Congress.
  • February 27, 2026: The VA formally rescinded the rule and restored the earlier regulation, which left the Ingram standard in place.
  • March 30, 2026: The Federal Circuit dismissed the VA’s appeal of Ingram after the government abandoned it. As a result, the Veterans Court’s decision stands as final.

What It Means for Your Musculoskeletal Rating

Under Ingram, an examiner evaluating your back, knee, shoulder, or other joint condition cannot treat the relief from your medication as a reason to rate the condition lower, as long as the diagnostic code does not mention medication. In practice, that gives you a basis to ask that your rating reflect the full severity of your condition.

Consider a veteran with a service-connected knee condition who takes a daily prescription anti-inflammatory. On a medicated day, the knee moves well, and an exam on that day may make the condition look mild. Without the medication, the knee swells and locks after a short walk. Ingram asks the examiner to consider how the knee behaves without the medication, not only on a medicated day. That fuller picture may support a higher rating.

The decision does not guarantee a particular percentage, though. Your rating still depends on the evidence, including your symptoms, limitation of motion, and functional loss. Ingram applies to diagnostic codes that do not mention medication, so a code that does may be treated differently. What Ingram requires is that your baseline be part of the evaluation.

How to Prepare for Your C&P Exam

Your exam is your chance to give the examiner the full picture. Because the VA must estimate your baseline, the information you share carries weight.

Take these steps to prepare for any upcoming C&P exam:

  • Bring a complete list of your medications: Include the name, dose, and how often you take each one.
  • Explain how each medication affects your symptoms: Describe what changes, such as less pain, more range of motion, or fewer flare-ups, and how long the relief lasts.
  • Describe your symptoms without medication: Tell the examiner what your condition was like before treatment began and what happens when a dose wears off or is missed.
  • Mention side effects: Drowsiness, stomach problems, and other effects are part of the full picture.
  • Describe your flare-ups: Say how often they happen, how long they last, and what you cannot do during them.
  • Keep your treatment records current: Your records should match what you tell the examiner.

This point bears repeating: Veterans should explicitly communicate their treatment details to C&P examiners. Veterans need to detail which medications they take and precisely how those medications reduce their symptoms. Documenting the exact relief provided by the medication ensures the examiner has the factual baseline required to calculate the true underlying severity of the musculoskeletal condition.

Be accurate in everything you share, and do not exaggerate. An honest, complete account is what supports your rating. Never stop or skip your medication before an exam to appear worse. Stopping treatment can harm your health, so talk with your doctor before you change any prescription.

What If You Already Have a Rating?

If your rating was set while you were on medication, it may be worth a second look because a higher rating could prove to be more accurate. The examiner may not have estimated your baseline, and the rating may not reflect the full severity of your condition. Depending on where your claim stands, your options may include a claim for an increase, a supplemental claim, a Higher-Level Review, or an appeal. Deadlines apply to each, so it helps to ask before you wait.

Whether Ingram applies to your situation depends on your diagnostic code, your medical records, and your claim history. An attorney from our firm can review those details with you.

Have Questions? Affleck & Gordon Has Answers.

The C&P exam is one of the most important parts of a VA disability claim, and the information you provide can influence your rating. At Affleck & Gordon, our firm has more than 45 years of experience helping individuals with disability claims, and we’d like to support you throughout the process ahead, too. Our VA-accredited attorneys handle VA disability claims from the first filing through appeals, so let us help you understand what an examiner needs, gather the right medical evidence, and pursue a rating that reflects your condition. If you already have a rating, we can review whether it is worth a second look and possibly a higher rating.

Call us at (404) 990-3945 or contact us online to schedule a free consultation and get more information from our team of attorneys.